Synopsis[ edit ] The book examines the history of scientific knowledge about the universe. It starts with the Ionian Greekswho claimed that nature works by laws, and not by the will of the gods. It later presents the work of Nicolaus Copernicuswho advocated the concept that the Earth is not located in the center of the universe. The presentation has been described as easy to understand by some reviewers, but also as sometimes "impenetrable," by others.
This form of assessment requires you to critically examine a piece of writing in the light of what you know about that field of research.
Your critical review is written for a reader your lecturer or tutor who is knowledgeable in the discipline and is interested not just in the coverage and content of the writing being reviewed, but also in your critical assessment of the ideas and argument that are being presented by the author.
Key steps in beginning your review To begin the task, you need to read and critically analyse the article.
When reading the text, have some questions in mind to guide your analysis and help you to focus on areas to critique.
The following questions are some ideas on how to engage with the text and help you form your critical analysis: If not, are there important theoretical assumptions?
Are they clearly defined? Are there specific hypotheses?
How adequate is it? When critically analysing the text, consider how it relates to your course materials, to the other articles or books that you have been reading and the lecture material.
This can help you find supporting evidence or alternative theoretical models or interpretations of data. Structuring the review The following is a suggested structure for your review.
Introduction Initially, identify the text author, title, date of publication and other details that seem importantindicate the main points you will be discussing and state your overall message regarding the text. Body Briefly summarise the range, contents, and argument of the text.
Occasionally you may summarise the entire text, but in a short review words you usually pick up the main themes only. This section should not normally take up more than a third of the total review.
Critically discuss key issues raised in the text. This section is the core of your review. Make clear the author's own argument before you criticise and evaluate it. Support your criticisms with evidence from the text or from other writings.
You may also want to indicate gaps in the author's treatment of a topic, but it is seldom useful to criticise a writer for not doing something they never intended to do.
Conclusion Evaluate the overall contribution that the text has made to your understanding of the topic and maybe its importance to the development of knowledge in this particular area or discipline, setting it in the context of other writings in the field.
Compare and contrast critical review Sometimes you will be asked to compare and contrast two or more journal articles in a critical review. The process is the same as above, however you will need to think about the following questions: What do the authors agree and disagree about? Which author's argument do you agree with the most, and why?
Keep these questions in mind as you read your journal articles and start to compare and contrast them.Every critical book review example offered in our website comes with a purpose.
For instance, if we offer you a critical history book review examples, it should not come to you as a text that does the simple job of summarizing the content of the history book.
It will go further to share information that is given in the book in a very critical manner. Order Custom Book Review from Our Service. Studies in high school, college, and university presuppose that various activities you are already familiar with become more complex as . Your review should have two goals: f irst, to inf orm the reader about the content of the book, and second, to provide an evaluation that gives your judgement of the book’s quality.
Briefly introduce the book and the book’s author, including biographical information about the author (education, training, experience, etc.). You may also mention other matters that you deem germane to introducing the book.
In most five-page reviews, you will likely need to . The part about capitalism that I find most important is its stability. It happens on its own if the government doesn’t bother. If the government tries to be helpful but misses some stuff, capitalism can take care of the details.
A critical book review is based on careful analysis and interpretation of a piece of literature. In the course of a book an author presents a variety of information and viewpoints, it is the critic's job to evaluate both the basic text and its information and the author's effectiveness as a writer.